It wasn’t to be for St Colman’s College who were well beaten today by St Patrick’s of Maghera in the Hogan Cup final at Croke Park. The Derry team were on top from first to last and ran out easy winners on a scoreline of 2-8 to 0-4.
St Colman’s will have little complaint about the result. It was a game in which they never got a proper toe-hold and, but for wayward shooting from the winners in the first half, in which St Pat’s recorded eight wides, partly explained by the tricky, swirling wind that blew around a baltic Croke Park, the game could well have been over as a contest at the half-way mark.
By then St Pat’s were five points to one ahead, Colman’s solitary point of the half coming on 18 minutes by their sole scorer, Darragh Beirne.
The Mayo lads really needed a strong start but it looked as if nerves were a factor early on for them, as they repeatedly fumbled the ball, allowing the opposition to turn over possession and drive up the field.
Still, when Colman’s finally opened their account, they were only two points in arrears. The four-point deficit they faced at the break was far from fatal too, even if the signs weren’t looking positive.
When Darragh Beirne hoisted over a superb second point, after McShane had scored for St Pat’s soon after the resumption, it gave the big, boisterous Colman’s support something to cheer about.
Those cheers were, sadly, silenced when Pat’s – sitting with fifteen behind the ball in what’s likely to be the last match any of us see played under the old rules – broke at pace and bore down on goal. Centre-back Haran finished it to the net and, with twenty minutes still left to play, that was effectively that.
Colman’s had a few late goal chances that came to nothing and Pat’s had a goal effort that cannoned back off the crossbar as the game finally opened up coming down the stretch. The Derry team, fittingly, had the final say when O’Neill found the net for them in injury time to seal a ten-point win and a sixth Hogan Cup title victory.

While today’s defeat will come as a bitter blow to the St Colman’s lads, as Colm Boyle points out in our Final Whistle pod (which will be up on Patreon shortly), their achievement in going on a run all the way to the final has given an enormous boost to Claremorris and the town is rightly proud of them, as is everyone connected to the school they’ve represented so well on the playing field.
For sure, they’ll have better days in the future. Today they were beaten by a far stronger team and there’s no shame at all in that. Hard luck to them and congrats to St Pat’s, who were worthy Hogan Cup winners today.


Ever the optimist says:
March 17, 2025 at 4:58 pm
Tough on the young lads out there today but systems in place - that were, no longer are -, onwards and upwards minus the conditioned ancien regime that served Ulster sides so well.
I, for one, will not miss any aspect of the old guard crap which rewarded siege mentality football.
Gizmobobs says:
March 17, 2025 at 5:02 pm
Hard luck St. Colman's great achievement to get so far, fair play to all involved.
St. Patrick's were excellent, moved the ball extremely well, turned defence into attack and attack into defence an excellent, controlled performance on their behalf.
Ontheditch says:
March 17, 2025 at 5:09 pm
A few good individual performances from St Colmans. Mark Noonan was outstanding for me. I'd like to see him still playing in a few years time.
catcol says:
March 17, 2025 at 7:26 pm
Is it the case that Ulster teams are older (longer at school in the UK system) than their Southern counterparts?
If so there are structural issues at play. If not, then I have to say that this was a shocking performance. Looked like Junior Certs versus Leaving Certs. Four points for an entire game! The body language was terrible. While St. Pat's were better all through they were so wasteful that the game was there for the taking half way through the second half - if there was anyone there to take it.
James Fleming says:
March 17, 2025 at 7:28 pm
Hard luck on the St Colman's team just didn't go their way today.
Ontheditch says:
March 17, 2025 at 8:06 pm
Credit to St. Colmans for getting to the final. St.Pats were a better unit, but St. Colmans had several good performances... not the end of the world....
Achill75 says:
March 17, 2025 at 8:43 pm
Colmans 330 boys
St Pats Maghera 1355 mixed 680 50% boys
Colmans punching well about there weight based on numbers, problem for Claremorris has been too many pupils in the locality moving to neighbouring schools of late.
Mary Mullen says:
March 17, 2025 at 10:54 pm
Mayo - St Colman's will be back - they always do!!
citog says:
March 18, 2025 at 12:03 am
I'm a fervent believer in a fact , that you must attack a pass. Colemans were on the attack today and a pass was delivered on approx. the forty when suddenly a St. Pats. man ran out past the intended Colemans recepient and started a Pats attack which resulted in their second goal.
MO2023 says:
March 18, 2025 at 3:01 am
St Colmans did great to reach the final but they must have regrets by losing by 10 after they abandoned their style used to get to final with playing 14 men behind the ball and giving up 70% possession to the Derry school. When shackles was off with a few minutes to go goal chances was created but was too little to late by then.
yew_tree says:
March 18, 2025 at 7:22 am
Achill75 - that’s a valid point. In my days Colmans had over 450 students. The decline in numbers has been dramatic which makes even getting to the final all the more remarkable.
Bonni Boyler says:
March 18, 2025 at 8:09 am
Was a tough watch yesterday, Colman's looked spooked in the first half. Never got a foothold in the game.
Second best all day long unfortunately.